Theory Choice and Social Choice: Kuhn versus Arrow
نویسنده
چکیده
منابع مشابه
Theory Choice and Social Choice : Kuhn versus Arrow
Kuhn’s famous thesis that there is ‘no unique algorithm’ for choosing between rival scientific theories is analysed using the machinery of social choice theory. It is shown that the problem of theory choice as posed by Kuhn is formally identical to a standard social choice problem. This suggests that analogues of well-known results from the social choice literature, such as Arrow’s impossibilit...
متن کاملArrow theorems in the fuzzy setting
Throughout this paper, our main idea is to analyze the Arrovian approach in a fuzzy context, paying attention to different extensions of the classical Arrow's model arising in mathematical Social Choice to aggregate preferences that the agents define on a set of alternatives. There is a wide set of extensions. Some of them give rise to an impossibility theorem as in the Arrovian classical mod...
متن کاملTowards a theory of MCDM: stepping away from social choice theory
The similarity between aggregation procedures in social choice theory and multicriteria decision aiding is well-known : the alternatives play the role of the candidates, the criteria play the role of the voters and the decision-maker plays the role of the society. Many authors, aware of this similarity, have used the formalism of social choice theory in multi-criteria decision aiding; see for e...
متن کاملArrow's Axiom and Full Rationality for Fuzzy Choice Functions
A classical result for crisp choice functions shows the equivalence between Arrow axiom and the property of full rationality. In this paper we study a fuzzy form of Arrow axiom formulated in terms of the subsethood degree and of the degree of equality (of fuzzy sets). We prove that a fuzzy choice function verifies Fuzzy Arrow Axiom if and only if it is (fuzzy) full rational. We also show that t...
متن کاملCompetitive Market Mechanisms as Social Choice Procedures
Social choice theory concerns itself with the proper choice of a social state from a given feasible set of social states. The main question the theory addresses is how that social choice should depend on the profile of individual preferences. Early work by Arrow and various predecessors, including Condorcet, Borda, Dodgson and Black, was about the construction of a social preference ordering — ...
متن کامل